Sustainable Substitutes for Alexa

A virtual assistant technology that inherits all of Amazons ethical and privacy concerns.

Reasons to avoid Alexa

Amazon's Alexa raises significant ethical concerns, from privacy violations, exploitative labour practices to lack of transparency.

Choose a more ethical, transparent, and sustainable alternative to Amazon Alexa.

Ethical and Sustainable Alexa Alternatives

Copied!
  • Feasibility: How easily can the average user switch to this substitute? Higher feasibility results in a higher ranking.
  • Editor's Rating: How sustainable is the substitute? The more sustainability attributes it fulfils, the higher it is ranked.

FHEM

A free and open-source home automation server with support for many protocols and hardware.

FHEM is ad-free, as it is a community-driven, open-source project with no reliance on advertising.
FHEM is designed to be self-hosted on a variety of hardware, from Raspberry Pi to dedicated servers.
FHEM works entirely offline, as it does not require an internet connection for local device control.
FHEM supports a modular architecture with over 430 device and protocol modules, allowing users to customize their setup extensively.
FHEM is completely free to use, with no mandatory costs for core functionality.
FHEM does not require any registration or account creation for local use.
FHEM runs locally on your own hardware, ensuring that your smart home data remains private and under your control.
FHEM is licensed under GPL v2, making it fully open-source and freely available for modification and distribution.
FHEM was created in Germany and is maintained by a European community.
Website

Home Assistant

A free and open-source home automation platform that doesn't store data in the cloud.

The entire Home Assistant platform is open-source, allowing users to view, modify and contribute to its codebase.
Home Assistant works entirely offline if self-hosted, as it does not require an internet connection for local device control.
Home Assistant supports a modular architecture, allowing users to add or remove integrations, plugins, and components as needed.
The core Home Assistant software is free to use, with optional paid services (like Home Assistant Cloud) that fund further development.
You can use Home Assistant without creating an account or registering, especially if you self-host it.
Home Assistant is designed to run locally on your own hardware, ensuring that your smart home data stays private and under your control.
Home Assistant itself is completely ad-free, as it is open-source and does not rely on advertising for revenue.
Home Assistant was created in the Netherlands and its development is supported by the Open Home Foundation, a European-based organisation.
Home Assistant is designed to be self-hosted on a variety of hardware, from Raspberry Pi to dedicated servers.
Website

openHAB

Open source automation software with support for all things home.

openHAB is designed to be self-hosted on a variety of hardware, from Raspberry Pi to dedicated servers.
openHAB works entirely offline, as it does not require an internet connection for local device control.
openHAB supports a modular architecture with a vast library of bindings (integrations) and add-ons, allowing users to customize their setup extensively.
openHAB is completely free to use, with no mandatory costs for core functionality.
openHAB does not require any registration or account creation for local use.
openHAB runs locally on your own hardware, ensuring that your smart home data remains private and under your control.
openHAB is fully open-source, allowing users to view, modify, and contribute to its codebase.
openHAB is ad-free, as it is a community-driven, open-source project with no reliance on advertising.
openHAB was founded in Germany in 2011 and is maintained by a global community
Website

The 8 main issues with Alexa

Big Tech - Big Tech companies do not nourish people and planet. This is especially true in times of political tension.

Amazon Alexa is a product of Amazon, one of the world’s largest and most influential tech corporations, embodying the concentration of power, data and market control typical of Big Tech. Its integration into daily life reinforces the dominance of a few corporations over digital infrastructure and consumer data. Source: WIRED: Here’s how I ditched Alexa and upgraded my smart home (2025)

Privacy Concerns - User data is likely to be stored and used against users' best interest.

Amazon Alexa has faced persistent criticism for its privacy practices. Amazon has removed privacy features (e.g., the “Do Not Send Voice Recordings” option) to push its new subscription-based Alexa+, forcing users to send all voice recordings to Amazon’s cloud. There are also concerns about the use of Alexa voice recordings in criminal trials and the company’s history of retaining recordings indefinitely, listening to audio and allowing employees to access private user data. Amazon’s lack of granular controls and transparency around how it uses personal recordings further exacerbates these issues. Source: Ars Technica: Everything you say to your Echo will be sent to Amazon starting on March 28 (2025)WIRED: Amazon's Alexa privacy efforts really aren't good enough (2025)Ars Technica: Alexa had “no profit timeline,” cost Amazon $25 billion in 4 years (2024)

Exploitative Labour Practices - Poor working conditions and low wages for workers involved in production or services.

Amazon’s hardware supplier, Foxconn, has been reported to violate labor laws by requiring teenage workers to work overtime and night shifts to produce Amazon Echo and Alexa devices. Reports indicate that Chinese schoolchildren as young as 16 were forced to work nights and overtime in Foxconn factories to meet production demands for Alexa devices. Source: The Verge: Amazon is investigating reports that teenagers in China were forced to work overtime building Echo speakers (2019)

Lack of Transparency - Opacity in operations, data handling, or supply chains, making it difficult for users to understand practices.

Amazon offers no transparency around how it processes or uses personal recordings collected by Alexa. The company’s bi-annual transparency reports also fail to clarify whether Echo data is handed over to governments, making it one of the least transparent major tech companies. Source: WIRED: Amazon's Alexa privacy efforts really aren't good enough (2025)Ars Technica: Everything you say to your Echo will be sent to Amazon starting on March 28 (2025)ZDNet: Amazon won't say if it hands your Echo data to the government (2018)TechCrunch: Amazon's barely-transparent transparency report somehow gets more opaque (2019)

Monopoly - Market dominance that stifles competition and limits user choice.

Amazon’s aggressive push to integrate Alexa into more devices and services—from speakers to smart home systems—reinforces its market dominance, often at the expense of smaller competitors and consumer choice. The company’s ability to bundle Alexa with other services and hardware creates barriers to entry for other voice assistant providers. Source: WIRED: Here’s how I ditched Alexa and upgraded my smart home (2025)

AI Bloat - Service has unnecessary or harmful AI features.

Amazon’s push to integrate generative AI into Alexa (e.g., Alexa+) prioritizes new features over privacy, efficiency, or user control. The company has removed privacy-focused options to support these AI-driven capabilities, forcing users to accept more data collection and cloud processing. Source: Ars Technica: Everything you say to your Echo will be sent to Amazon starting on March 28 (2025)

Support of Authoritarian Regimes - Companies actively supporting, financing and legitimising regimes and unethical policies.

Amazon and Jeff Bezos support Donald Trump's agenda.Source: EthicalConsumer.org: The relationship between Amazon and Trump: profiting from power (2025)

Tax Avoidance - Aggressive strategies are being deployed to avoid paying taxes.

Amazon's tax strategies have been widely criticised for aggressive tax avoidance practices.Source:Wikipedia: Amazon tax avoidance

Suggestions and Feedback

If you have suggestions for more alternatives or general feedback, please contact me via email or create an issue over on Codeberg. Suggest Substitute on Codeberg Write an Email